SOCIOLOGY! Explain the differences between the two models and assess the strengths and weaknesses for each

There are a number of differences between the biomedical and the socio-medical model. The biomedical model focuses on health as being just the absence of disease. This means that it looks at the physical functioning of an individual and ill-health is described as being presence of an illness diagnosed through signs and symptoms from an injury, meaning environmental factors are ignored. The socio-medical model differs however as it focuses on social factors which contribute to the health and well-being of an individual within society. They highlight that environmental and social conditions are contributors of illness/disease and so instead of an individual approach; it focusses on communities and populations in order to promote health. The socio-medical model links easily with the conflict theorists as they believe that short life expectancy and higher morbidity rates among less fortunate individuals are due to the inequalities of the society (Billingham et al 2007). However, the biomedical model links easily with the functionalist perspective as illness is regarded as being dysfunctional for society (Billingham et al 2007). Regarding both models there are strengths and weaknesses. There are a number of advantages to the biomedical model. This model focuses on curing an individual’s illness/disease. Due to this some illness that used to be very fatal can now be cured e.g. some cancers. This is therefore a result of the development of successful treatments due to research being carried out. Health professionals have been well trained and have reliable information/knowledge regarding illness and how they can be treated. Due to this individual’s trust the doctors and other health professionals to cure their illness/disease. If the individual’s health improves it then proves that the doctor is professional and effective. This model relies on ojective and measurable observations and so it is said to be enticing. It also means that findings may be more reliable due to it being succinct (Zigmond, 2012). There are, however disadvantages to this model also. Individuals with a condition such as Downs’s syndrome are not focuses on as the biomedical model sees these individuals as not being normal. A doctor may not be interested in helping an individual with this kind of condition as the doctor’s expertise may not benefit the individual’s quality of life. It means that if an individual with downs syndrome and an individual seen as being normal needed heart surgery which was very expensive, the individual with the condition would not get it. This is because the biomedical model would see this as being wasteful as the individual who is seen as being normal may benefit more from the surgery. The biomedical model doesn’t consider social and environmental factors which can cause illness. The model focuses on biological factors and that medicines can cure illness/disease but completely ignores that it may be environmental factors such as damp within housing which could bring about illness/disease (Coward 1989). Doctors quite often don’t see people as an individual but see them as a case meaning that the treatment provided is due to illness/disease and not by the individual themselves. They tend to label individual with illness in groups even though the illness may be different. An example of this may be two individuals who have the same type of cancer however they illustrate different signs and symptoms and respond to treatments differently. The socio-medical model also has advantages. This model doesn’t just try to find a treatment for an illness/disease, it looks at what causes the illness e.g. environment, diet, mind-set. It then aims to treat the cause. It doesn’t focus on the individual itself but a society as a whole. It takes into consider environmental and social factors and how they can impact the population. There is research to back up information making it more reliable. In the late 19th century there was research carried out which confirms that when living conditions were improved in the UK there was an increase in life expectancy and mortality rates decreased (Billingham et al, 2007). This therefore improved health and reinforces that in this case it was environmental and social factors that caused illness/disease. This model believes that too much money is provided to the medical professionals and not enough given to communities in order to help individuals to improve their living standards. This could help to prevent illness/disease, having a healthier society. Like always, there are also disadvantages to this model. It will take more time to solve an individual’s problems as unlike the biomedical model, the socio-medical model treats the cause of the illness and it may take a longer period of time to find the root cause. Trying to motivate the population into choosing a healthier lifestyle may also be very difficult. Persuading smokers to quit smoking and encouraging individuals to eat healthier isn’t always easy. It will also be difficult to measure the effectiveness of this method. Individuals may not always be reliable in the information that the provided and so it would mean the findings therefore would not be reliable as it would not be a true finding. Dont forget to leave a wee comment!! xo

PUBLIC HEALTH P2 M1

Hey Guys,

Describe the origins of public health in the UK. (P2) Compare historical and current features of public health. (M1)

Public health refers to all organized measures, whether it is public or private, to prevent disease, promote health, and prolong life among the population as a whole. Its activities aim to provide conditions in which people can be healthy and focus on entire populations, not on individual patients or diseases. Thus, public health is concerned with the total system and not only the eradication of a particular disease. It encompasses the science, the art and the politics of preventing illness and disease and promoting health and well-being. Public health also addresses inequalities present in health which frequently explain large variations in health locally, nationally and globally.

The industrial revolution is the name given to the period of the 18^th and 19^th century where Britain transitioned to the development of new manufacturing techniques making more food available. This meant that by 1901 the population had increased to about 30 million and people began to migrate to urban locations also known as urbanisation. Due to a large amount of the population moving at once, it created problems such as overcrowding as they couldn’t build enough houses for the large increase in population. Communities lacked facilities and were deemed unsanitary as there was no sewage system, drainage and no clean water. Due to the living conditions, communicable diseases where very common and could spread quickly.

The Board of Health was set up to give advice on preventing the spread of fever in February 1805. The early 1830’s had seen the following activity which was prompted by the threat of a cholera epidemic and in June 1831 the consultative Board of Heath was again set up. The regulations where to prevent the spread of cholera and by November 1831 the Central Board of Health was established and local boards began to set up. In 1834, the Poor Law Act was passed by parliament which ensured that poor people had housing, were clothed and also fed. However, if they wanted this they had to go into a workhouse to receive it. They were given these things in exchange for several hours of manual labour each day. The conditions were made harsh and so that only people who desperately need it would go there.  

In 1842, Edwin Chadwick had published a report on the ‘Sanitary Condition of the Labouring Population of Great Britain’. Chadwick argued that disease was directly related to living conditions and that there was a desperate need for public health reform. He noted that people lived in dirty, overcrowded conditions and this caused illness, leading to people becoming too sick to work and a higher tax expenditure on helping them. Due to this Chadwick introduced a set of solutions which would help improve public health. He suggested that sewers should be improved, rubbish should be removed, clean water should be provided and medical officers should be appointed to check each area. This helped because with an improved sewerage system, human waste would not contaminate the water supply and therefore a fall in cholera and other related communicable diseases would be noticed.  Removing rubbish would stem the increase in pest and the development of disease and the medical officers would check that all these reforms were being obeyed. At this time there was an attitude of lazzise-faire, which was the belief that the government should not interfere in the lives of ordinary people or business. However, another cholera epidemic in 1848 causing 21,000 deaths, led the government to try out some of Chadwick’s ideas.

The public Health Act was then finally passed in 1848 and it set up a General Board of Health, Chadwick being one of its three commissioners. This allowed local Health Boards to be set up in towns, however, this was only where the mortality rate is higher than 23 per 1,000. The Act also encouraged a local medical officer to be appointed and also allows them to organise rubbish removal and to build a sewage system. However, only one third of towns set up a Board of Health and even fewer appointed a medical officer. The terms of the act were only temporary and by 1854 the three commissioner had to resign and the General Board of Health was done away with in 1858.

In London, 1854, John Snow mapped the cholera epidemic and had discovered an infected water pump on Broad Street as the source. The result of this discovery was that cholera was now identified as a water borne disease and Snow then became recognised as a pioneer of epidemiology.

As a result of people disposing their human toxic waste into the river, it lead to The Great Stink in London when the river Thames was full of raw sewage. This smell was overpowering and it had permeated Parliament to be adjourned. Joseph Bazalgette (1819-91) however, eradicated this by designing and building a sewer system.

In 1861, the upper class realised that they too had just as much reason to be concerned when Prince Albert dead as a result of typhoid. This then proved that the wealthy people, could also be susceptible to infectious disease. The first stage in the development of social housing was when Octavia Hill began her campaign in 1864, to improve the housing of working people to a decent standard.

There was a fourth Cholera epidemic in 1866, which caused 6,000 deaths. The Sanitary Act made sanitary inspectors compulsory in cities and demanded that the local governments provides fresh water. Overcrowding, which was a major cause of disease, became classified as being a ‘nuisance’. Also in 1869, the Peabody trust had built cheap flats that provided good living conditions and are of a good quality in London. These buildings are still used to this day.

By the time of 1914, the basic legislative framework had been created to improve the health of the population and the government had accepted a share of the responsibility for this. During the Second World War, in 1942, William Beveridge had written a report on how Britain ought to be rebuilt. The report was designed to encounter the five great evils which included, want, disease, ignorance, squalor and idleness.

The welfare was formed when the government changed in 1945, which aimed to provide free medical treatment and social security so that people are protected from the cradle to the grave. The government had now accepted responsibility for promoting and protecting the health of the public.

When comparing historical and current features of public health we are able to see that there has been many changes. In the 19^th Century the diseases that were prevalent were known as communicable diseases. Communicable diseases are caused by micro-organisms, such as viruses and bacteria. These diseases can be transmitted from one individual to another (Walsh et al). An individual may use the words 'contagious' or 'infectious' when they are talking about communicable diseases. They usually include virus, fungus, bacteria and protozoa. Examples include small pox, TB, typhoid and also diseases which are associated with malnourishment. These diseases were so prevalent due to a number of reasons. Firstly, there was a lack of knowledge and education. This meant that people were unable to learn about the different types of communicable diseases and so couldn’t try and prevent it. They may not have even known what the disease was, how it was caused or what the symptoms of it were. Another reason why the diseases were so prevalent was because of the poor living conditions. People were living in cramped conditions with a large number of people and so disease was easily spread, this meant that if one person got it, everyone around them would also get it. There was also no health service to help prevent disease and so vaccinations or medicine was unavailable, there was a lot of poverty and also a lack of government intervention.

Studies of disease were carried out particularly by John Haygarth and John Snow. These studies mapped diseases and showed a link between the spread of the disease and the area. John Snow found the link between bacteria and living conditions. He found that bacteria caused disease within the body of people rather than their living conditions. The government eventually listened to Chadwick and decided to then try out his ideas. His report led to the Public Health Act being passed in 1848 and local Health Boards where set up, encouraging the appointing of a medical adviser and also allowing the organisation of rubbish remover and the building of a sewage system. In the mid 1900’s, the Beveridge report then furthered the involvement of the government and they began to take responsibility of the health of the public. He also suggested the establishment of the National Health Service and this was then development in 1948.

In 1822, Pasteur and Jenner came together in the development of the vaccination process and this combined with the invention of antibiotics e.g. penicillin. The focus was on infection, and immunisation programmes were set up improving the knowledge of the population.

In the early 20^th century there were environmental reforms meaning that there was the clearance of slums and the population was being provide with a clean water supply. This then prevent disease and the number of infections therefore decreased.

Non communicable diseases such as heart disease and cancers became the big killers in the mid-20^th century. This was link to the lifestyle of the individuals and they were then blamed for their own ill health, which was often the reason for the behaviour being ignored. This led to the New Public Health order, which approached and addressed the causes of the causes e.g. poverty, poor housing and unemployment in a bid to improve the health and well- being of the population.

In the UK the most prevalent non communicable disease is lung cancer and there are 42,026 people who have lung cancer, 23,175 in men which are 55% and 18,851 in women, 45%. This gives a ratio of male to female of more than 12:10. The crude incidence rate shows that there are 76 new lung cancer cases for every 100,000 males and 60 for every 100,000 females. Lung cancer is so prevalent mainly due to the lifestyle choice in which people choose. Smoking accounts for 80-90% of global lung cancer deaths in males. Non-smokers on the other hand account for only around 10-20% of lung cancer.  Altogether around 41,000 people are diagnosed each year in the UK with lung cancer. In addition a further 3% of lung cancer cases are caused by exposure to second hand smoke in non-smokers.

Public health is now managed by a number of different agencies such as the Department of Health, NHS, Public Health Agency, DHSSPSNI and also GP.

The PHA was established in 2009 under a major reform of health structures in Northern Ireland. They were set up to provide a renewed and more enhanced focus on public health and well-being by bringing together a wide range of public health functions under the one organisation.

The DHSSPSNI has a mission to improve the health and social well-being of the population in NI. They had three main responsibilities including HSC, including policy and legislation for hospitals, family practitioner services and community health and personal services. Public health is another responsibility which covers policy, legislation and administrative action to promote and protect the health and well-being of the population and also public safety, which cover policy and legislation for fire and rescue services.

Your studypal

X 

PUBLIC HEALTH P1 AND P5

Hey everyone, so this assignment was P1 and P5 for public health!!

Describe key aspects of public health strategies (P1) Explain health promotion and protection (P5).

There are many strategies in public health to ensure that the population stays healthy, and has a longer life expectancy. Public health is now managed by a number of different agencies such as the Department of Health, NHS, Public Health Agency, DHSSPSNI and also GP. The DHSSPSNI has a mission to improve the health and social well-being of the population in NI. They had three main responsibilities including HSC, including policy and legislation for hospitals, family practitioner services and community health and personal services. Public health is another responsibility which covers policy, legislation and administrative action to promote and protect the health and well-being of the population and also public safety, which cover policy and legislation for fire and rescue services.

To ensure the Department of Health achieve their aims, the government needs information about how health the population are. They need to find out the mortality and morbidity rates and often ask individuals to complete surveys rating their own health.  It is important for the government to monitor these as it keeps track of the statistics for both mortality and morbidity rates and also allows them to be able to identify the actions that need to be taken for example if they need to improve on their health campaigns or set up new facilities and undergo more recent research to improve on the statistics.  There are over 41,000 people diagnosed with lung cancer each year (NHS, 2013). A further 3% of lung cancer cases are caused by exposure to second hand smoke in non-smokers. Lung cancer is known to be the second highest cancer to affect the UK. The more you smoke will certainly increase the likelihood of developing lung cancer however it is the length of time that you have been a smoker that is the most important factor (cancer research, 2014). Approximately 2.3 million people in the UK are living with Coronary Heart Disease (CHD) (NHS, 2014). The main causes for CHD are hypertension, diabetes, high cholesterol and also smoking (NHS, 2014). Around 800,000 people in the UK are affected by dementia (NHS, 2015). This risk of developing dementia usually increases as individual age. The mortality rates in Northern Ireland alone, in 2013 were 14,968 (NISRA).

An aspect for strategies of public health is to identify the health needs of the population and to develop programmes to reduce the risk and screen for early onset of disease. When the government have recognised and are aware of the population’s health status, they will then concentrate on their resources on key health issues. One key health issue is cancer and bowel cancer is known to be one of the most common cancers which is diagnose in the UK, with approximately 40,000 new cases each year (NHS, 2014). The Northern Ireland Bowel Cancer Screening Programme is offered to all men and women who are aged 60 to 74 every two years. Individuals within this age group will be sent a screening test so that they are able to do the test at home (HSC, 2011).  This is done by taking a sample of the faeces, and when completed, sent to a laboratory to be tested for any signs of blood. If blood traces are recognised the individual may be then sent for a further colonoscopy. An abdominal aortic aneurysm or (AAA) is when the main artery in the body widens as it passes through the abdomen. The artery balloons out as the walls weaken. This is more common in those who smoke, who have high blood pressure, those with cardiovascular disease and also in older men (HSCNI, 2015). If this is not treated, it can be fatal and 80-100 individuals in Northern Ireland die from a ruptured AAA each year.  The Northern Ireland AAA screening programme was implemented in 2012 and is offered to men in their 65^th year in Northern Ireland. Its aim is to reduce AAA mortality by providing a systematic, population based screening programme which uses a simple ultrasound scan (HSCNI, 2015). For those who undergo the ultrasound screening a reduction in mortality to 45% has been highlighted in men between the ages of 65 and 79 years.

Another key aspect is controlling communicable diseases. Any outbreaks of infectious diseases must be investigated and should be controlled by the DOH to protect the public. The Health Protection Service has a role in protecting the population from environmental hazards and also infections and it is delivered by a multi-disciplinary team (HSCNI, 2015). The DOH make individuals aware of diseases like influenza by having posters and leaflets in for example doctor surgeries and clinics, in which individuals are able look at and take away with them. This can be telling them how disease is spread and what can be done to prevent it. To control seasonal flu the DOH are giving immunisations to those who are at most risk from this disease including, the elderly, young children, asthmatics and diabetics. This reduces the likelihood that these individuals will come in contact with this disease.

A further key aspect is promoting the health of the population. Health promotion is motivating individuals to increase control and responsibility over their own health and improve it by changing their lifestyle and behaviour. The DOH wants to reduce the mortality and morbidity rates of disease/illness in Northern Ireland. This is done by setting out health campaigns which often use the fear approach in order to shock or fear the individuals into changing their behaviour. An example of a health campaign is the, “is your waistline creeping up on you?” poster which was used to support the, “choose to live better” campaign (PHA, 2011). This is also a television advertisement. On the poster it shows a man with a waistline of 37” and ‘cancer’ wrote on the band on his underwear. This shows that if men of a certain age have a waistline of 37” or more then it can be seen as a health risk and could therefore lead to cancer.  During the year of 2011, over 4,000 individuals from across Northern Ireland had been surveyed about a variety of health and wellbeing issues. In relation to obesity, the CMO report stated that 59% of the adults that were measured were either overweight (36%) or obese (23%). Males were seen to be more likely overweight (44%) than females (30%). This therefore make men who have a waistline like this think twice about it, and so may persuade them to change their lifestyle to lose weight as they may have a fear of developing cancer due to being overweight. This can be linked to the victim model. It suggests that people have limited influence over their health and that it may be determined by genes and by social and economic environments.  There is a link between obesity and social class. This suggests that poverty limits choice. Individuals and families who have a lower income have less choice in the food that they are able to buy and therefore eat. This is because processed, junk food tends to be cheaper than it is to eat healthily. A diet that is processed is loaded with the wrong nutrition, for example high in fats and carbohydrates and so leads to obesity. In addition low income individuals often live in areas where there are few facilities for healthy, safe exercise. This model highlights that people who have low income are victims of economic circumstances.

Another campaign is, “every cigarette rots you from the inside out”, which features a father lighting a roll-up cigarette made of rotting flesh (BBC, 2015). The aim of this campaign is to try to shock smokers into giving up. It also highlights the belief that hand rolled cigarettes are just as harmful as normal, packed cigarettes. The statistics for those who smoked hand rolled cigarettes in 1990 was 18% for males and 2% for females. In 2011 this had a big increase to 40% males and 26% females (action on smoking and health, 2015). In 2013, the opinions and lifestyle survey highlighted that 40% male and 23% females smoked hand- rolled cigarettes. These figures are almost still the same as they were in 2011. This can be linked to the empowerment model which suggests that individuals are empowered and have a free choice, meaning that they are free to choose between a healthy and unhealthy lifestyle. They are the ones who decide what they are going to spend their money on whether it be cigarettes or not.

The fifth key aspect is planning and evaluating the national provision of health and social care. The DOH sets out plans each year for health and social care and they must measure how successful they have been by carrying out an evaluation. It is beneficial to set targets as it gives you a laser focus, so that all the attention is set on one area at a time. This means that the DOH can put attention on to one key area at a time to give it a better chance of being achieved. Targets will also help make good decisions as they will help to identify and establish priorities and make right choices based on long term views and in this case what’s important for the population. This is when the evaluation comes into play in that, if the targets have not been met the DOH are able to look back on them along with statistics and therefore see where they have gone wrong and what needs to be changed and improved. 

Leave a wee comment and let me know if you find this useful.

Your studypal 

X

Whats this??

Hey everyone,

I currently study Health Science at college and when I am completing my assignments/coursework and I need help, I often look online to see if anyone has done the same piece. So I thought that I would post each piece of my own written work on a blog so that if anyone else needs help, its there as I have found it useful.

This blog would be mainly for those who are studying health and social care, health science or something similar, although there are quite a few topics!

You will hear from me again soon!
From your study pal!
X




<a href="http://www.bloglovin.com/blog/14908219/?claim=93ww5haz2sm">Follow my blog with Bloglovin</a>